During the fall of the Trinity, heroes and villains began working together to rebuild their land. Wanting to take this opportunity to rule the realms, Rumplestilskin discovers that two specific people hold the key to help him gain tremendous power. Knowing that they live within the neighboring town, he summons clones and shape-shifts them into mundane townsfolk during the day; at night they sneak out and murder one villager in their sleep.
After several victims begin surfacing, rumor spreads that Rumplestiltskin is hiding amongst them. Will the townsfolk be able to keep their wits (and heads) to find out which one of them should be burned at the stake? Or will the frailty of trust end up tearing them apart from within? Rumplestiltskin offers a re-imagined take on the game concepts of Werewolf and Mafia, using well-known characters like The Little Mermaid, Red Riding Hood, Briar Rose, and Mad Hatter.